神爵元年(前61),七十多歲的趙充國在金城,手裡有一支要去打先零羌的兵。他上的屯田奏,第一句不是講地,是報帳:「臣所將吏士馬牛食,月用糧穀十九萬九千六百三十斛,鹽千六百九十三斛,茭藁二十五萬二百八十六石。」——所部吏士、馬、牛的月帳;《通典》在這一句下注「石,百二十斤」。後面整篇都繞著這筆月帳轉:不是能種多少地,而是有多少糧要人從別處運來。

一個月十九萬九千六百三十斛

這筆帳是全軍一個月的量。同一篇裡,朝廷調發的各路兵「合六萬人矣」——六萬人,加上馬牛,一個月吃掉近二十萬斛糧穀。數字後緊接著一句:「難久不解,繇役不息。」仗拖下去,徭役就停不下來。這是他算的帳:錢糧不是花在打上,是花在「等」和「運」上。

事情起於先零羌反。宣帝問誰可帶兵,他說「亡踰於老臣者矣」;到金城後堅壁不戰,只等對方疲弊。朝廷等不及,皇帝的璽書下來催他趁天時進兵,信裡把難處說得很直:「今張掖以東粟石百餘,芻槁束數十。轉輸並起,百姓煩擾。」——張掖以東,粟一石百餘錢,草料一束數十錢;轉輸一起,百姓煩擾。一封催戰的信,先把轉運的帳擺出來。趙充國回奏說「擊之不便」,隨後上屯田奏:撤掉騎兵,留一萬人在當地種田,等羌人自己垮。

二千頃與一萬二百八十一人

地是現成的:「計度臨羌東至浩亹,羌虜故田及公田,民所未墾,可二千頃以上,其間郵亭多壞敗者。」——從臨羌東到浩亹,羌人舊田和公田、百姓沒有開墾的,估計二千頃以上;沿線的郵亭壞了不少。這個數是「可」,是估計,也不是已經種熟的田。同一篇裡他還報了預備工作:「臣前部士入山,伐材木大小六萬餘枚,皆在水次。」——先前派兵入山,砍了大小六萬多根木材,都堆在水邊。木材是留給後面修亭、架橋的。

留下的人是這樣湊的:「願罷騎兵,留弛刑應募,及淮陽、汝南步兵與吏士私從者,合凡萬二百八十一人,用穀月二萬七千三百六十三斛,鹽三百八斛,分屯要害處。」——撤騎兵,留下來的共一萬二百八十一人,一個月用穀二萬七千三百六十三斛、鹽三百八斛。緊接著一句最要緊:「今大司農所轉穀至者,足支萬人一歲食。」——大司農已經運到的穀,夠這一萬人吃一年。種田的人先吃運到的舊糧,等新穀下來,轉運就可以停。

賦人二十畝

每人種多少,原文只有一句:「田事出,賦人二十畝。」——春天田事開始,分給每人二十畝。《通典》在句下注:「田事出,謂至春人出營田也。賦謂班與之。」「賦」是分給的意思。二十畝是分配數,不是每人實際耕了二十畝,更不是產量。兩頁都沒有說這二千頃最後開出多少、一畝打多少、總共收多少;這些數不給,也不替它算。

屯田不止是種地。同奏還有一串活:「冰解漕下,繕鄉亭,浚溝渠,治湟陿以西道橋七十所,令可至鮮水左右。」——冰化時放木下漕,修鄉亭、浚溝渠,整治湟陿以西道橋七十所,直到鮮水一帶。到四月草長起來,再從郡裡和屬國調胡騎「伉健各千,倅馬什二,就草,為田者遊兵」——各一千精騎,十匹裡帶兩匹副馬,來草地放牧,給種田的人當遊兵。十二條便宜裡,他把「以閒暇時下所伐材,繕治郵亭,充入金城」也單列一條:農閒時把砍下的木材放下,修郵亭,送進金城。

與轉粟比的那筆帳

最硬的一句在第四條便宜:「軍馬一月之食,度支田士一歲,罷騎兵以省大費,四也。」——軍馬一個月的吃用,折算起來夠田士一年;撤掉騎兵,省下大費。他算的不是收成,是替代。第一條說「因田致穀,威德並行」,末了總一句:「屯田內有亡費之利,外有守禦之備。」——裡面省了運費,外面還有守備。動機他也說得很直:「今久轉運煩費,傾我不虞之用以澹一隅,臣愚以為不便。」——拖下去,轉運煩費,把防備意外的錢倒進這一個角落。

不出兵也有帳。另一個方案是辛武賢的:七月出擊,每人帶三十日糧。趙充國替這個方案算負擔:「以一馬自佗負三十日食,為米二斛四斗,麥八斛,又有衣裝兵器,難以追逐。」——一馬自負三十日食,米二斛四斗、麥八斛,再加衣裝兵器,追不上人;路又「回遠千里」。他還回頭算了一筆更早的帳:金城、湟中「穀斛八錢」,他曾勸耿中丞糴二百萬斛,說這樣「羌人不敢動矣」,結果耿中丞請糴一百萬斛,只得到四十萬斛。就近買糧沒買夠,剩下兩條路:繼續從遠處運,或者讓兵自己種。

什三、什五、什八

朝議不是一開始就同意的。班固寫得很清楚:「初是充國計者什三,中什五,最後什八。」——起初贊成者不過十分之三。丞相魏相說:「後將軍數畫軍冊,其言常是,臣任其計可必用也。」皇帝於是報:「今聽將軍,將軍計善。其上留屯田及當罷者人馬數。」——聽你的;把留屯與該撤的人馬數報上來。但結果是「兩從其計」:破羌、強弩兩將軍仍然出擊,趙充國獨自留下屯田。

第二年五月,他報戰果:「羌本可五萬人軍,凡斬首七千六百級,降者三萬一千二百人,溺河湟飢餓死者五六千人,定計遺脫與煎鞏、黃羝俱亡者不過四千人。」——羌人本約五萬兵,斬首七千六百,投降三萬一千二百,溺死餓死五六千,最後逃散的也不過四千。然後「請罷屯兵」,奏可,振旅而還。這筆帳要看清楚歸屬:屯田沒有獨自打贏,三路兵都出動了;屯田管的是「不再從遠處運」,戰果是三路合起來報的。兩頁沒有畝產、總產,沒有說這些田的租稅歸誰,也沒有說屯田兵的家口在哪。還有一層邊界:《通典》屯田條按朝代往下排,漢之後是魏、晉、隋、唐;那是編者的編排,不是「屯田從漢延續到魏」的沿革證據,許下屯田、鄧艾淮南屯田也不在本篇。

延伸閱讀:賞什麼,幾件:兩份周代賞賜清單 · 錢缿:戰國市集怎麼運轉 · 交鈔:一張紙六個名字,越改越輕

參考來源與延伸閱讀

  1. 《汉书》卷六十九·赵充国辛庆忌传(东汉班固;维基文库本,未与点校本复核) — The farm memorial in full, which is the spine of the article. The monthly bill: 'the officers, men, horses and cattle under my command use each month 199,630 hu of grain, 1,693 hu of salt, and 250,286 shi of fodder' (臣所將吏士馬牛食,月用糧穀十九萬九千六百三十斛,鹽千六百九十三斛,茭藁二十五萬二百八十六石), followed by 'if the affair is long unresolved, the corvée will not stop' (難久不解,繇役不息); the same chapter says the levies came to 'sixty thousand men in all' (合六萬人矣). The imperial letter pressing an attack, which states the prices and the burden: 'east of Zhangye grain is more than a hundred cash a shi and a bundle of fodder several tens; transport has been raised on every side and the common people are harassed' (今張掖以東粟石百餘,芻槁束數十。轉輸並起,百姓煩擾). The land: 'reckoning from Linqiang east to Haomen … two thousand qing or more; and the post stations are mostly ruined' (計度臨羌東至浩亹……可二千頃以上,其間郵亭多壞敗者). Timber: 'more than sixty thousand pieces, all stacked by the water' (伐材木大小六萬餘枚,皆在水次). The force kept: '10,281 in all, using 27,363 hu of grain a month and 308 hu of salt' (合凡萬二百八十一人,用穀月二萬七千三百六十三斛,鹽三百八斛), with 'the grain already brought by the Grand Minister of Agriculture enough to support ten thousand men for a year' (足支萬人一歲食). The works: 'when the ice breaks, float the timber down; repair the post stations, clear the ditches, and put in order the roads and bridges west of the Huang gorge, seventy of them' (冰解漕下,繕鄉亭,浚溝渠,治湟陿以西道橋七十所), and horsemen 'with spare mounts at two in ten, to graze and serve as patrols for the farmers' (倅馬什二,就草,為田者遊兵). The twelve benefits: the first (因田致穀,威德並行), the fourth (軍馬一月之食,度支田士一歲,罷騎兵以省大費), and the timber-and-post-station item (以閒暇時下所伐材,繕治郵亭,充入金城); then 'garrison farming has the profit of no expense within and the preparation of defence without' (屯田內有亡費之利,外有守禦之備) and 'transport is long and troublesome and expensive, draining what we keep for the unforeseen to water one corner' (今久轉運煩費,傾我不虞之用以澹一隅). Xin Wuxian's alternative and its load: 'one horse carrying its own thirty days' food — two hu four dou of rice, eight hu of wheat' (以一馬自佗負三十日食,為米二斛四斗,麥八斛), over a road 'a thousand li roundabout' (回遠千里); Zhao's retrospect on local prices, 'grain at Jincheng and Huangzhong eight cash a hu' (金城、湟中穀斛八錢), against which he had urged two million hu and seen four hundred thousand bought. The shift in opinion: 'at first three in ten agreed, midway five, at the end eight' (初是充國計者什三,中什五,最後什八), Wei Xiang's endorsement, the emperor's 'now I follow the general', and then 'he followed both plans' (兩從其計). The next year's report: five myriads of Qiang, 7,600 beheaded, 31,200 surrendered, five or six thousand drowned or starved, 'no more than four thousand' escaped (定計遺脫……不過四千人), and the request to disband the farm (請罷屯兵).
  2. 《通典》卷二·食货二·屯田(唐杜佑;维基文库本,未与点校本复核) — The Tang compilation's garrison-farm section, which carries the same memorial abridged with notes. It supplies the note on units — 'a shi is 120 jin' — and, crucially, the gloss on the allotment sentence: 'the field work begins means that in spring the men go out to work the fields; fu means to distribute to them' (田事出,謂至春人出營田也。賦謂班與之), which is why twenty mu must be read as an allotment and not as area actually ploughed or as a yield. Its Han section also has an earlier entry, Emperor Zhao's first yuan year (85 BC), when 'shooting soldiers were sent to Shuofang and former officials were appointed to lead garrison farming in Zhangye commandery' (發習戰射士詣朔方,調故吏將屯田張掖郡), a reminder that Zhao's plan was not the first of its kind; but the page then runs on by dynasty through Wei, Jin, Sui and Tang, and that arrangement is the compiler's, not evidence that the institution ran unbroken from Han to Wei. The Wei entries on this page (Xu Xia's fields at Xuchang, Deng Ai on the Huai) are excluded here and belong to the site's Wei article.